Experts are forecasting that insurer control of the collision repair industry
will intensify. The common term for this process is disintermediation, the
process whereby customers lose direct contact the business that provides the
goods or services. When you buy produce at a Farmers market, for example, buyer
and grower are in direct contact. When you purchase produce at a grocery store
the grower becomes disintermediated from the buyer. Insurers will try very hard
to impose tight controls over body shops. Whether or not insurers succeed in
wresting power away, however, depends on whether or not shops surrender
control.
Legislation signed by Nebraska Governor Dave Heineman restricts
employer use of employee social security numbers. Omaha Sen. Steve Lathrop, the
bill's introducer, said LB 674 would help reduce identity theft. The bill
prohibits employers from posting more than the last four digits of a Social
Security number; requiring an employee to transmit more than the last four
digits of his or her Social Security number over the Internet unless encrypted
or over a secure connection; requiring the use of more than the last four digits
of a Social Security number to access an Internet site; and using more than the
last four digits of a Social Security number as an employee number. Violation of
the Nebraska new law is a Class V misdemeanor.
The Nebraska Autobody
Association released the top fiver insurers as selected by collision repair
shops for the 2006 calendar year. The top five insurers for 2006 are: (1) State
Farm; (2) Farmers Mutual; (3) Union Insurance; (4) Columbia National; and (5)
AAA.
"This industry is about to choke and expire," body shop owner Sean
Butler said in recent testimony. Boston Now quoted Butler: "We're here to ask
this house to save a dying patient." Massachusetts's repairers are backing
Alliance of Automotive Service Providers efforts to establish a Labor Rate
Commission that would validate rates insurers must pay. AASP hired a top
lobbying firm to help make its case. Labor rates, according to AASP, were $30
per hour in 1988 and increased to just $34 per hour in 2007, a timid 13 percent
change in nine years while the cost of living for the same period jumped 46
percent. In other labor rate news, the newly formed National Collision Industry
Alliance is exploring the labor rate issue as it relates to individual state
laws. "Reimbursements are part of state insurance regulations," said NCIA
founder Norbert Zaenglein, "that may provide a legitimate basis for ongoing
validation of labor rates and other insurance claims settlement practices to
ensure and verify that reimbursements are in compliance within state pricing
laws, rules and regulations."
Airbags are migrating to unusual
places and multiplying, according to an article in the Detroit News. Airbags
will be placed beneath the dashboard, in back seats, under seat cushions and
even on seat belts. The distinction of having the most airbags in a vehicle goes
to the 2008 Toyota Lexus, which will have a total of ten airbags. Analysts
predict that the numbers of inflatable restraint systems will increase to an
average of eight to ten per vehicle.
Legislation passed in Minnesota
would prohibit insurers from adjusting shop estimates without conducting a
physical inspection. The law becomes effective August 2007. Specifically, the
statute reads: "No adjuster or insurer, director, officer, broker, agent,
attorney-in-fact, employee, or other representative of an insurer shall in
collision cases: "adjust a damage appraisal of a repair shop when the extent of
damage is in dispute without conducting a physical inspection of the vehicle; or
specify the use of a particular vendor for the procurement of parts or other
materials necessary for the satisfactory repair of the
vehicle."
Questionable insurance company claims settlement practices
continue to make headlines. A flood of trials for mishandling Katrina claims is
scheduled for this summer in Mississippi. In the meantime legislators are
struggling to find solution to prevent future claims settlement catastrophes.
The aftermath of Katrina has also impacted homeowner insurance rates some of
which, according to Mississippi's Sun Herald, are approaching the cost
mortgage payments. Meanwhile weather forecasters are predicting a wave of
hurricanes this year. Colorado State University predicts seventeen named storms
nineteen of which are expected to be hurricanes.
North Dakota State Rep.
George Keiser, last month, asked his state attorney general if the National
Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) can conduct meetings that are
closed to the public. The issue at hand is whether or not open record laws are
violated when the Insurance Commissioner partakes in closed executive sessions.
Keiser asked, "Can the state of North Dakota…participate in policy and
regulatory discussions if said discussions are off-limits to the public?" Keiser
said he would introduce a bill to rectify the issue. But NCOIL has also come
under criticism for being too cozy with the insurance industry. Criticism stems
from NCOIL's mission of drafting model legislation and helping legislators
regulate the insurance industry. A study released by the Consumer Federation of
America (CFA) in 2003 reported that at least 40 percent of NCOIL's leadership
had ties to the insurance industry. According to the CFA, NCOIL "has taken a
series of recent positions on high-profile insurance issues that are favorable,
if not identical, to insurance interests and have frequently undermined consumer
protection."